zlacker

[parent] [thread] 1 comments
1. pessim+(OP)[view] [source] 2023-08-02 14:55:47
I have huge problems with Cloudflare, but this comment is dishonest.

[1] "Hello, Benedikt from Cloudflare and the Turnstile Team here. Thanks you so much for the report. We looked into this report and identified that there was some false positive and cleared the signal. We have investigated this report and the issue should be fixed. Please reach out to me benedikt@cloudflare.com or at our Cloudflare Turnstile Discord, if you are still encountering problems."

[2]

> Servers commonly use passive and persistent identifiers associated with clients, such as IP addresses or device identifiers, for enforcing access and usage policies. For example, a server might limit the amount of content an IP address can access over a given time period (referred to as a "metered paywall"), or a server might rate-limit access from an IP address to prevent fraud and abuse. Servers also commonly use the client's IP address as a strong indicator of the client's geographic location to limit access to services or content to a specific geographic area (referred to as "geofencing").

> However, passive and persistent client identifiers can be used by any entity that has access to it without the client's express consent. A server can use a client's IP address or its device identifier to track client activity. A client's IP address, and therefore its location, is visible to all entities on the path between the client and the server. These entities can trivially track a client, its location, and servers that the client visits.

> A client that wishes to keep its IP address private can hide its IP address using a proxy service or a VPN. However, doing so severely limits the client's ability to access services and content, since servers might not be able to enforce their policies without a stable and unique client identifier.

> This document describes an architecture for Private Access Tokens (PATs), using RSA Blind Signatures as defined in [BLINDSIG], as an explicit replacement for these passive client identifiers. These tokens are privately issued to clients upon request and then redeemed by servers in such a way that the issuance and redemption events for a given token are unlinkable.

replies(1): >>supriy+9c
2. supriy+9c[view] [source] 2023-08-02 15:47:14
>>pessim+(OP)
Please see [1] regarding the concerns around attestations and PAT and [2] for what has happened outside HN, which a simple reading of that thread wouldn't otherwise suggest.

[1] >>36972051

[2] >>36971869

[go to top]