zlacker

[parent] [thread] 3 comments
1. manuel+(OP)[view] [source] 2021-05-24 16:45:10
Only Galileo would be a candidate here. And he was not mocked, he was put on trial for something most academics knew since ancient times.

What you call "dismissive", is just reactionary traditionalism.

Also, all of these provide evidence to support their claims.

> But even the current mRNA vaccine developers were dismissed for 15-20 years as unimportant.

This. This is the problem, right here.

You believe that mainstream media works like science, and it does not. So when big headlines hit the public opinion with things like "this woman was mocked and now her work on mRNA is the basis of the new vaccines", you take that the academic world actually dismissed those novel ideas.

Science does not work like that. And the media like hyperbole. And that hyperbole is what stucks the most in the public memory.

replies(1): >>Turing+5k
2. Turing+5k[view] [source] 2021-05-24 18:17:14
>>manuel+(OP)
> you take that the academic world actually dismissed those novel ideas.

She was denied tenure.

replies(1): >>manuel+7p
◧◩
3. manuel+7p[view] [source] [discussion] 2021-05-24 18:43:31
>>Turing+5k
She wasn't. She was denied funding, and for that you can blame the bureaucrats, not the academia.

"In 1990 she was offered a tenure track position at the University of Pennsylvania. Around this time, a different group of researchers developed a technique for injecting mice with RNA in such a way that those mice started to produce the proteins encoded by the RNA. [...] After six years of work at the University of Pennsylvania, due in part to a lack of interest from funding agencies in supporting her work, Karikó was demoted from her tenure track position. This type of demotion generally leads to the end of a scientific career. In the same year, she was treated for cancer and her husband encountered a visa problem, leaving him temporarily stuck in Hungary."

https://www.advancedsciencenews.com/pioneers-in-science-kata...

replies(1): >>Turing+gd1
◧◩◪
4. Turing+gd1[view] [source] [discussion] 2021-05-25 00:12:50
>>manuel+7p
> Karikó was demoted from her tenure track position. This type of demotion generally leads to the end of a scientific career.

She was on the tenure track, and didn't get tenure.

That's denial of tenure.

Funding agencies provide funding based on grant reviews by... academics. So yeah, academics dismissed her novel ideas.

[go to top]