zlacker

[parent] [thread] 5 comments
1. antiso+(OP)[view] [source] 2025-10-28 16:24:37

    I bet now you’d kill for a senior thesis based on my free, multilingual, publicly cited, text-based articles, motherfucker
Yeeeeeeeeah.... Not if it's written in or about the Scots language.

(see: https://www.theregister.com/2020/08/26/scots_wikipedia_fake/ ) (see also: that time the Scottish governmment used Scots wikipedia as a source)

replies(2): >>thepup+J6 >>IAmBro+Eb
2. thepup+J6[view] [source] 2025-10-28 16:52:05
>>antiso+(OP)
Wasn't that an edge case, though? Not even done by a bad actor, just someone misguided? And it was discovered and quickly corrected, unlike what would happen on something owned by a massive FAANG-style corp.

I have been schooled many times on the failures of Wikipedia, why I shouldn't waste my time editing it, how the editors are toxic; but ultimately, I can't help but buy into the idea of a crowdsourced, centrally administrated, store of knowledge.

I wouldn't base critical decisions off of Wikipedia alone, but it sure helps me understand things in general.

replies(2): >>philip+Mm >>antiso+ec1
3. IAmBro+Eb[view] [source] 2025-10-28 17:11:28
>>antiso+(OP)
You've cherrypicked 0.0006% of Wikipedia... that has been corrected.
replies(1): >>antiso+oc1
◧◩
4. philip+Mm[view] [source] [discussion] 2025-10-28 17:56:32
>>thepup+J6
> And it was discovered and quickly corrected

It was definitely not quickly corrected. It was going on for years.

◧◩
5. antiso+ec1[view] [source] [discussion] 2025-10-28 21:35:13
>>thepup+J6

    > Not even done by a bad actor, just someone misguided?
I'm not sure how the actor's good intentions makes the information on the wiki accurate?

    > quickly corrected
As others have pointed out, it was certainly not "quickly" corrected. And to clarify on "corrected", about half the content on that wiki was simply deleted. A bunch of actual useful edits were definitely removed. And that didn't happen before the Scottish government used it as a source.
◧◩
6. antiso+oc1[view] [source] [discussion] 2025-10-28 21:36:03
>>IAmBro+Eb
Or another way of saying it would be that I've "cherrypicked" literally the majority of Scots wikipedia.
[go to top]