zlacker

[parent] [thread] 3 comments
1. oefrha+(OP)[view] [source] 2025-05-06 13:44:15
The differentiator of Cursor is it’s way smarter at basic code completion than GitHub Copilot. I pay for Cursor instead of GitHub Copilot even though I get the latter for free from open source contributions, and I made that decision after five minutes of usage after using Copilot for what, more than a year? I won’t even talk about how Cursor guesses where I’m going to edit next and makes the correct edit most of the time, just the fact that Copliot makes completions that result in unbalanced parentheses/braces all the time and Cursor doesn’t makes the switch a no-brainer; that’s not even a fucking AI problem, you just need to look around and see that function you just completed already has a closing curly brace, all it takes is some traditional AST analysis if your model is dumb. (Copilot made zero progress on that issue during my time using it, but I can’t say if that was fixed after I ditched it.)
replies(2): >>moi238+fo >>petefo+8Z
2. moi238+fo[view] [source] 2025-05-06 15:54:45
>>oefrha+(OP)
My experience is the same. And the agent mode in copilot is terrible, it simply will stop halfway through files.

Or you chat and suddenly it wants to use the azure copilot instead because reasons.

Horrible experience.

3. petefo+8Z[view] [source] 2025-05-06 19:37:57
>>oefrha+(OP)
Same. Cursor might be the only tool I've purchased a year's subscription to before the end of my free trial.

I've tried just about every model on its own over the years, and yet there's something about the Cursor workflow that frequently still gives me chills when it shows me again that it had clearly anticipated what I would think next in a way I just don't experience with other tools.

Holistic seems like the right word?

If it's all smoke and mirrors as some folks imply, then it's Penn and Teller level smoke and mirrors. Beware those who tell you that they could duplicate anything of value in a weekend.

replies(1): >>kaptai+372
◧◩
4. kaptai+372[view] [source] [discussion] 2025-05-07 07:49:07
>>petefo+8Z
Windsurf does it all the time like a wife of 40yrs completing your sentences. A good example is when you remove a function parameter. It automatically prompts to remove the arguments in all usages of the function, saving me a lot of time.
[go to top]