zlacker

> dividing immigrants into "good ones" and "bad ones" is pretty vile, but as an american i must acquiesce we've played that game for a long time. before hispanics it was asians, before asians it was europeans (the irish particularly.)

This is just an entirely incorrect reading of what the grandparent comment said.

They are not saying that immigrants from some places are good, and immigrants from some other places are bad (or immigrants of one ethnicity vs. another). Regardless of whether you agree with them or not (which is a very valid thing to disagree with, if that’s how you feel), they explicitly said that the US gets “good” immigrants from those groups, while Canada gets more “mediocre” immigrants from those exact same groups.

There is no classification or separation by nationality/ethnicity going on in the grandparent comment, despite you treating it like there is.