zlacker

[parent] [thread] 4 comments
1. s_dev+(OP)[view] [source] 2023-11-22 07:53:57
I don't think the dangers of AI are not 'Skynet will Nuke Us' but closer to rich/powerful people using it to cement a wealth/power gap that can never be closed.

Social media in the early 00s seemed pretty harmless -- you're effectively merging instant messaging with a social network/public profiles however it did great harm to privacy, abused as a tool to influence the public and policy, promoting narcissism etc. AI is an order of magnitude more dangerous than social media.

replies(1): >>disgru+1m
2. disgru+1m[view] [source] 2023-11-22 10:59:08
>>s_dev+(OP)
> Social media in the early 00s seemed pretty harmless -- you're effectively merging instant messaging with a social network/public profiles however it did great harm to privacy, abused as a tool to influence the public and policy, promoting narcissism etc. AI is an order of magnitude more dangerous than social media.

The invention of the printing press lead to loads of violence in Europe. Does that mean that we shouldn't have done it?

replies(2): >>logicc+Nr >>kubect+vD
◧◩
3. logicc+Nr[view] [source] [discussion] 2023-11-22 11:51:13
>>disgru+1m
>The invention of the printing press lead to loads of violence in Europe. Does that mean that we shouldn't have done it?

The church tried hard to suppress it because it allowed anybody to read the Bible, and see how far the Catholic church's teachings had diverged from what was written in it. Imagine if the Catholic church had managed to effectively ban printing of any text contrary to church teachings; that's in practice what all the AI safety movements are currently trying to do, except for political orthodoxy instead of religious orthodoxy.

◧◩
4. kubect+vD[view] [source] [discussion] 2023-11-22 13:16:35
>>disgru+1m
> Does that mean that we shouldn't have done it?

We can only change what we can change and that is in the past. I think it's reasonable to ask if the phones and the communication tools they provide are good for our future. I don't understand why the people on this site (generally builders of technology) fall into the teleological trap that all technological innovation and its effects are justifiable because it follows from some historical precedent.

replies(1): >>disgru+Bg5
◧◩◪
5. disgru+Bg5[view] [source] [discussion] 2023-11-23 19:30:25
>>kubect+vD
I just don't agree that social media is particularly harmful, relative to other things that humans have invented. To be brutally honest, people blame new forms of media for pre existing dysfunctions of society and I find it tiresome. That's why I like the printing press analogy.
[go to top]