Am I misunderstanding his answer, or does he not essentially say it should be "descriptive"? In which case, I misunderstood what your comment is implying.
>>ohblee+(OP)
Sorry for being vague. I was not at all referring to his answer per se. But rather his high-brow reference to Plato.
If he has truly read and digested Plato (and not just skimmed a summary video), he would not be in this ditch to begin with. That's the irony I was referring to.