zlacker

In that case, "strength" is the wrong metric. If you're posting a shallow response just because the facts align with your position, you're still just wasting people's time.

The people who already agree that the article is shallow learn nothing, and the people who don't know the article is shallow also learn nothing.

And I agree with you, position strength is tied to facts, which is why writing a shallow dismissal instead of listing some facts leads to a weak position.

Incidentally, why are you responding to me and not just saying "you're wrong, I'm done talking to you."