zlacker

I think you don't need all four. Just agree/disagree/bad. Agree is a positive. Disagree might be positive depending on various factors (# of replies, etc). Bad is the negative.

>>wvenab+(OP)
Hmm that's fair. I personally like to have agree/disagree as neutral value judgements, but it could work pretty well with agree as a positive too.

Either way, I feel like the XenForo reactions/Slashdot ratings system probably works better if you want to avoid the upvote/downvote abuse that sites like Reddit have, since they make people think about why they like/dislike a post rather than treating it like a binary matter.