She did do a ton of research, worked through all the materials we sent her (I sent a lot, including a thwack of Kids in the Hall videos, several years-long email threads with specific users, with their permission of course, and god knows what else), and even changed her mind—a thing rare enough to always deserve respect. We took a risk in trusting her; I felt like it worked out, and I'm glad we chose to be open. The article came out fairer than we probably had any grounds to expect. There were bits I could complain about, but that's inevitable. I felt seen and I think Scott did too.
Re Canute, she missed that pvg was being playful, in the context of a longstanding positive connection. I felt bad when I saw that. But we did get an amusing, and properly italicized, About box out of it: https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=pvg.
Come back, pvg!