zlacker

[parent] [thread] 4 comments
1. superk+(OP)[view] [source] 2023-07-08 14:55:04
That's just because google is a corporate person who is more equal than a human person. Human persons, at least in the USA, get charged under the CFAA 1030 law if they're using non-browser tools to access the public website of someone with power and/if they happen to rock the boat (like weev w/wget).

That's not to say that I disagree. In most cases robots.txt is not legally binding. It only becomes a legal danger to not follow it when the person running the site has power and can buy a DA to indict you.

replies(2): >>rafark+hv >>TeMPOr+981
2. rafark+hv[view] [source] 2023-07-08 17:57:26
>>superk+(OP)
If a tool can access a url, does that not make it a browser?
replies(1): >>TeMPOr+s71
◧◩
3. TeMPOr+s71[view] [source] [discussion] 2023-07-08 22:10:36
>>rafark+hv
Not under any but most narrow of meanings, i.e. "can follow URLs / can talk HTTP". By itself, it's not a browser to users, it's not a browser to software developers, and it's definitely not a browser to lawyers and judges.
replies(1): >>rafark+Ig1
4. TeMPOr+981[view] [source] 2023-07-08 22:16:57
>>superk+(OP)
> like weev w/wget

Speaking of this and other cases of trying to punish someone for every iteration of a for loop - I wonder if the result would be the same if the accused drove actual browser to click stuff in a for loop, vs. using curl directly. I imagine the same, but then...

... what if they paid N people some token amount of money, to have each of those people do one step of the loop and send them the result? Does executing a for loop entirely on in part on the human substrate instead of in silico is seen as abuse under CFAA?

(I have a feeling that it might not be - there's lots of jobs online and offline that involve one company paying lots of people some money for gathering information from their competitors, in a way the latter very much don't like.)

◧◩◪
5. rafark+Ig1[view] [source] [discussion] 2023-07-08 23:40:43
>>TeMPOr+s71
Is there a legal definition of a web browser though? I think it’s an interesting topic.
[go to top]