zlacker

[parent] [thread] 5 comments
1. ent101+(OP)[view] [source] 2023-06-14 01:11:46
I highly suspect anything critical of Reddit is being flagged to death on HN. This post was #1 with more than 100 upvotes in 39 minutes. Now it keeps going lower and lower.
replies(2): >>ent101+r >>dredmo+Qs
◧
2. ent101+r[view] [source] 2023-06-14 01:13:42
>>ent101+(OP)
Now it's #6. How's this even possible?!
replies(2): >>arcane+j1 >>CamelC+x1
◧◩
3. arcane+j1[view] [source] [discussion] 2023-06-14 01:19:21
>>ent101+r
I've noticed this place seems to have a really high churn rate. I often find myself replying to comments that are only 5 minutes old. :P
◧◩
4. CamelC+x1[view] [source] [discussion] 2023-06-14 01:20:06
>>ent101+r
Inciteful posts rank lower. Incitefulness being ranked as some function where upvotes increase the score and number of comments decreases it.
replies(1): >>Jtsumm+j3
◧◩◪
5. Jtsumm+j3[view] [source] [discussion] 2023-06-14 01:30:54
>>CamelC+x1
Yeah, dang's discussed that in the past. Among other factors for ranking is the comment:upvote ratio. And I think quality of comments and discussion, they have a flamewar detector (speed of replies and depth of comment thread nesting) which can also impact ranking.
◧
6. dredmo+Qs[view] [source] 2023-06-14 05:25:58
>>ent101+(OP)
That's most probably based on member flags, not moderator action.

Note that HN also deprecates stale stories, where "stale" includes "ongoing discussion of some present drama", e.g., bitcoin and NFCs last year, or GPT currently.

dang's discussed this occasionally, see: <>>35463948 >

HN specifically doesn't moderate posts critical of YC company down, though Reddit's so long out of the gate I'm not sure that still applies. See: <>>35463948 >

There've been 116 stories mentioning "Reddit" with > 20 votes between 2023-5-13 and 2023-6-14.

<https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1686720501&dateRange=custom&...>

I'm doing analysis based on HN front page listings and could update that to see what the actual surviving front-page story count is. It's been ... fairly substantial.

Fewer than 3% of submissions make the front page, and that's exclusive of spammed or moderated content.

Update / Edit:

There've been 16 front-page stories on Reddit since 31 May beginning with "Had a call with Reddit to discuss pricing" (<>>36141083 >).

As compared with prior years, the 2023 mention rate is well above both the 5- and 10-year history (showing year and HN front-page mentions of "Reddit"):

  2007 41
  2008 31
  2009 15
  2010 44
  2011 41
  2012 46
  2013 28
  2014 27
  2015 27
  2016 19
  2017 15
  2018 15
  2019 12
  2020 24
  2021 12
  2022 13
  2023 21
(Source: own data & analysis based on a crawl of all HN front-pages through 2023-06-13.)
[go to top]