If that is the entire content of the article and it has no context to which it is addressed, I think its pointless, but, no, I see no reason in your hypothetical or any obvious extension to see it as disingenuous.
I also don’t see it as particularly usefully analogous to the situation previously being discussed.
I get what you’re saying though. With sentencing, I feel like the maximum sentence is always given, and while dramatic it is very common to see.