My comment was in response to you asking whether the other user (who as far as I can tell was not posting any false information about PHP, just pointing out that they personally preferred other languages?) wanted _recognition_, from you personally, for having learned some other language.
This is such a weird reaction to have to the idea that someone has learned, and/or would rather use, some other language. I hope you can see that.
Of course, it's not just you. I have never seen any programming language community that feels _threatened_ by the idea of other languages existing and being learned, in the way that the PHP community does.
Fundamentally, this is a learned social behaviour, which means that whether or not individual PHP developers know other languages does not matter. A community that treats acquiring additional knowledge as a _threat_, seeing learning from the outside world as a _betrayal_, will not be able to learn _from_ other languages.
As bringing new ideas and thoughts into the community is socially discouraged, it will only be possible for learning to flow in one direction: away from the PHP community.
I asked what prompted the person to type that kind of reply. Had you read the entire topic, you'd see plenty of false info being posted, but my point remains: you used PHP, you moved on, what prompts you to be active in topic about PHP where all you contribute with is "I moved on."
> This is such a weird reaction to have to the idea that someone has learned, and/or would rather use, some other language. I hope you can see that.
And we're in territory of mental gymnastics now :)
You think the reaction is to learning another language? You're obviously a programmer. Can you tell me how many possible outcomes exist and how come you chose this one in particular?
Reaction was not to learning another language, it's ridiculous.
> I have never seen any programming language community that feels _threatened_
You never read linux mailing list and c vs c++? I can't take you seriously, you talk as if there exists de-facto "community". There isn't one, it's just a bunch of people who use various forums and there's no coherent community. You interacted with several people and you label that community and then you purposely shove words that haven't been written only to challenge them.
It's a straw man argument.
You persist in labeling PHP devs so narrow-minded that they chase away people who learn other languages. I don't know which (human) language I need to use, but it's apparent that this is becoming multiplayer monologue. I write one thing, you claim I wrote something else and then you generalize based on it.
Notice: I haven't tried to provide my "credentials" by listing what languages I know or what I do. I never even stated I'm a PHP dev.
You, on the other hand, labeled me and entire PHP community as weak-ego, tribalists who frown upon other languages and that the PHP community, which apparently you researched somehow, is different to all other communities - which you also apparently researched. In this whole wall of text you wrote, you have't asked a single question. You merely stated something and then you proceeded to take up the higher moral ground and then demean people. Do you think such discourse is productive?
> Fundamentally, this is a learned social behaviour, which means that whether or not individual PHP developers know other languages does not matter. A community that treats acquiring additional knowledge as a _threat_, seeing learning from the outside world as a _betrayal_, will not be able to learn _from_ other languages.
In this very topic, I wrote about features I'd like to see in PHP - one being generics. Something I learned in C# and something that changed my entire stance to JS because of having used in TypeScript.
That's just _one_ example of how you assume without zero facts to go by. I won't bother listing what we do for feature suggestions in PHP, which languages have great features and what we do to bring them in. You're just incapable of reading and you merely recognized me as a "bad guy" because I called someone out. I seriously doubt you'll read this, it would take more than 13 seconds of attention and that's something hard to acquire these days.
TL;DR: nice gaslighting and straw man, thanks for ad-hominem, I wish you well in the new year :)
> Had you read the entire topic, you'd see plenty of false info being posted
I've honestly looked through all of the original poster's comments and couldn't find any misinformation. Except for referencing r/lolphp, which is indeed mostly wrong about everything.
> You think the reaction is to learning another language? [...] Can you tell me how many possible outcomes exist and how come you chose this one in particular?
I thought so, although I see now that I was wrong. I still don't understand what else your response, saying "Do you want recognition for learning other languages?" to a comment saying "I no longer use PHP and I have learned other languages that I actually like", was supposed to be reacting to, but I take it that there are other possible interpretations that I'm not grasping here.
> you talk as if there exists de-facto "community". [...] it's just a bunch of people who use various forums and there's no coherent community
Obviously a community as big as the PHP community is always going to be, in turn, fragmented into smaller communities. Symfony is not Laravel is not WordPress. But that doesn't mean that you can't draw generalisations from it, like how you would say "the Python community is scared of big breaking changes". This doesn't mean that every single member of that community is personally scared of big breaking changes. It's a generalisation about the behaviour of a group that doesn't extend into a judgement of each and every one of its members.
> You, on the other hand, labeled me and entire PHP community [...] which apparently you researched somehow
I thought there was no such thing as a PHP community. I described a general vibe that I perceive from a given community, which I have extensively interacted with and been a part of. Unless it doesn't exist, in which case I suppose I haven't.
I then compare it to other communities, which I have also interacted with and been a part of, if they indeed exist. My perception nonetheless may be flawed, and it does not need to apply to you specifically.
> I wrote about features I'd like to see in PHP
It's great that what I said above does not apply to you. Your personal appreciation of other programming languages' features, in turn, does not change what I perceive as the broader community's culturally enforced commitment to willful ignorance.