zlacker

> So obviously the source of the error is one or more third parties, not Microsoft, and it's obviously impossible for Microsoft to be responsible in advance for what other people claim to license.

No. Look at the insane YouTube copystrike situation. Why shouldn't Microsoft be held to the same standards?

>>matheu+(OP)
I can't tell what you're arguing. You seem to be suggesting that YouTube is doing insane things, and that therefore... Microsoft should also be doing insane things?

Also a major problem with YouTube is not with DCMA itself, but it how it implements the system to allow for abusive takedowns without repercussions for the abusers.