zlacker

[parent] [thread] 0 comments
1. fivre+(OP)[view] [source] 2020-06-25 07:10:59
> Software can kill if we put blind trust in it and give it full control over the situation. But we shouldn't do that.

Do you work in a commercial software firm? Have you ever seen your salespeople talk with their customer contacts?

The salespeople and marketing departments at the firms that make this technology and target law enforcement markets are, 100%, full stop, absolutely making claims that you can trust the software to have full control over the situation, and you, the customer, should not worry about whether the software should or should not have that control.

Being able to use something "irresponsibly" and disclaim responsibility because AI made the decision is. a. selling. point. Prospective customers want. to. give. up. that. authority. and. that. responsibility.

Making the sort of decisions we ask this shit to make is hard, if you're a human, because it's emotionally weighty and fraught with doubt, and it should be, because the consequences of making the wrong decision are horrific. But if you're a machine, it's not so hard, because we didn't teach the machines to care about anything other than succeeding at clearly-defined tasks.

It's very easy to make the argument that the machines can't do much more, because that argument is correct given what tech we have currently. But that's not how the tech is sold--it becomes a miracle worker, a magician, because that's what it looks like to laypeople who don't understand that it's just a bunch of linear algebra cobbled together into something that can decide a well-defined question. Nobody's buying a lump of linear algebra, but many people are quite willing to buy a magical, infallible oracle that removes stressful, difficult decisions from their work, especially in the name of doing good.

tl;dr capitalism is a fuck. we can pontificate about the ethical use of the Satan's toys as much as we like; all that banter doesn't matter much when they're successfully sold as God's righteous sword.

[go to top]