I also find the comment about needing to learn a new stack “React Native and Xcode” to be ridiculous– no, what needs to be learned is Swift and Xcode.
Far too many “web” developers consider native mobile to be some kind of subset of web development and thus expect to use the same tools as they use for web.
Web is a different medium! If you want to program embedded systems, then the first question isn’t “how can I do this with JavaScript?” They would learn the correct language for the platform, perhaps embedded C. You don’t launch a Linux server and then ask “how can I make this server run Windows? I guess I should write a JavaScript library for that!” It’s ludicrous.
With iOS, developers often just think of it as a “native” website rather than an actual application. It seems like some developers will do everything possible to avoid simply learning Swift and making actual apps that fully exploit the power of the device.
React Native – if that is considered “good” then we have major problems. Facebook applications are horrible at power management; they suck power at phenomenal rates compared to other applications. The smoothness of the UI isn’t as “native” as actual Swift apps coded correctly. There always seem to be a slight amount of glitch in the experience. Facebook has famously avoid actually coding real native apps – from the beginning of their mobile experience they have seemingly embraced doing everything except writing actual Swift or Objective C. It is almost a religious opposition to it – and despite being a multi-billion dollar company, some tiny app studio in Poland could write higher quality apps. It should be an embarrassment, but they’re Facebook so everyone just accepts the status quo of less than perfect. No person here can say that the Facebook apps are perfect. But they should be. They have a gazillion dollars and can hire almost anyone they want, so they have no excuse for anything less than perfection. At the very least get power management right!
There’s always this argument that x-Native is “good enough” – if, as a company you want “good enough,” then keep making apps that conform to the lowest common denominator. If you want to make extraordinary applications that move the needle of quality, then use Swift and build it correctly.
This will likely get downvoted into oblivion because the HN crowd seems to be exhaustingly enamored with React Native, however, regardless of how it’s framed, writing PWAs or using some cross-platform “solution” is a cop-out. It’s lazy and it provides users with an experience that is worse than they deserve.
iOS is better than Android in so many ways, yet developers insist on making iOS apps that are really just cross-platform compromises.
My tiny bootstrapped company is working to release our iOS app, with Android soon to follow – if we can do it, there seems little excuse for actual funded companies to skimp on providing the best experience for users. Those arguing that PWA or x-Native cross platform systems are just as good as actual native, well there is no amount of argument that will change your minds. Which is sad. Rather than trying to make React Native, etc. “better” why not just use what is already better? Why not let users enjoy the full power of their devices instead of writing these average “good enough” compromises. It’s like this ridiculous trend of using Electron or, in the past Adobe Air. Nowhere near the quality of writing an actual native app. Looking at you Slack. Slack is even proud to have made a “native app with web technologies.” WHY? Damnit make a native app with native technologies! Can you not hire two actual MacOS developers? Why should making Electron apps be celebrated? It’s sloppy. It’s lazy. It’s a disservice to users. Why use some Electron-wrapped webpage and just not the webpage?
Every day it seems on HN people are posting about <some language> but very few posts about Swift. Is there some opposition that I am missing? Why must JavaScript be the language of everything? what ever happened to picking the right language for the job rather than trying to force a web peg into a native hole.
By the way, my exact arguments could be made for Android development as well. Android users are also being short-changed by these pseudo-native cross platform “solutions.”