zlacker

>>iafish+(OP)
I wonder what is the closest thing to Cyc we have in the open source realm right now. I know that we have some pretty large knowledge bases, like Wikidata, but what about expert system shells or inference engines?

>>mepian+pe
I tried to make something along these lines (https://truebase.treenotation.org/).

My approach, Cyc's, and others are fundamentally flawed for the same reason. There's a low level reason why deep nets work and symbolic engines are very bad.

>>breck+yy
And what is that reason?

>>eschat+SM3
The language before language.

>>breck+A05
Care to expand on this, provide evidence, or even pointers to what you mean by it?

>>eschat+XE5
Pardon the cliffhanger style.

I have begun crafting an explanation, but not sure when it will be ready.

But when you recognize that thinking predates symbolic language, and start thinking about what thinking needs, you get closer to the answer.