zlacker

[return to "The Odyssey by Homer, Translated by Samuel Butler"]
1. devind+VF[view] [source] 2023-07-17 17:02:07
>>agomez+(OP)
As always I think your best move if you want to read a work with many translations available is simply to read the first 2-3 pages (or some other short identical segment) and see which one feels best to you. I have read several and I value them all for different reasons.

I love Pope but wouldn't read him for an "accurate" translation (he didn't know Greek!) and I like Butler's prose but it's a total transliteration, not poetry. My go-to recommendation is Lattimore (not Fagles, which I found dull), but now we have Emily Wilson in the mix too (with a great preface to boot).

Taste them all and go with whichever is best for you - you can always read another later, but your first time for a classic should be enjoyable and natural. Only you can say which one you enjoy most.

◧◩
2. verisi+BX[view] [source] 2023-07-17 18:12:32
>>devind+VF
My, I get the impression that 'translations' are far more like a work of art in their own right, than, er, a translation!
[go to top]