zlacker

[return to "Show HN: Freenet 2023, a drop-in decentralized replacement for the web"]
1. rascul+P21[view] [source] 2023-05-20 14:01:43
>>sanity+(OP)
Not sure what is meant by a drop in replacement in this context.

Normally I would think a drop in replacement would mean I could switch to it and do everything the same as I was doing it. But my guess is that if I did this drop in replacement that little to none of the web activities I partake in would work anymore. So maybe my thoughts aren't quite what is meant.

◧◩
2. sanity+G41[view] [source] 2023-05-20 14:17:12
>>rascul+P21
It's a drop in replacement for everything north of the user's web browser - so it's drop-in from the perspective of the user, but centralized services need to be recreated for it. We're already working on a decentralized messaging system as a proof of concept, others will follow.
◧◩◪
3. rounda+W91[view] [source] 2023-05-20 14:57:47
>>sanity+G41
I'm not thrilled to see a discussion of contracts.. How do the system designers intend to avoid a speculative tulip market for small amounts of processing? Can anyone bring up all the computing they would ever need by plugging it into the Internet?

The P2P aspect looks much better, but naturally there's the question of how this is differentiated from something like Tor with .Onion sites?

◧◩◪◨
4. sanity+nz1[view] [source] 2023-05-20 17:51:45
>>rounda+W91
> I'm not thrilled to see a discussion of contracts

They're not contracts in the sense of a cryptocurrency, they're contracts in the sense that code and cryptography are used to control how data is used and updated in the system, similar to a database ACL, or object encapsulation in OOP.

This is a generalization of a concept called "signed subspace keys" in the original Freenet, which predated Bitcoin by almost a decade.

> The P2P aspect looks much better, but naturally there's the question of how this is differentiated from something like Tor with .Onion sites?

.Onion sites and services are still centralized, their server's location is just hidden by Tor. With the new Freenet the services themselves are entirely decentralized and can operate entirely independently of the person or people that created them.

[go to top]