zlacker

[return to "Hundreds of changes made to latest editions of Roald Dahl's books"]
1. stucki+a2[view] [source] 2023-02-18 18:25:59
>>GavCo+(OP)
Censoring old children's books. Yikes. This is frightening in more ways than one.

Besides the obvious censorship, and rewriting the past being a bad thing. I can't wait to see what they do to "Brave New World", "Fahrenheit 451" and "1984". It'll be ironic and sad if they burn the old unedited Roald Dahl books.

But also have we reached cultural stagnation, that old media still out competes new ones by such orders of magnitude ?

This is a huge problem, when every year we graduate more and more people wanting to be writers, artists, etc. This will only get worse with books now being written by ChatGPT and art by Dall-E/Midjourney/Stable Diffusion.

Have we reached "peak multimedia" content ?

◧◩
2. jemmyw+Id[view] [source] 2023-02-18 19:34:32
>>stucki+a2
> But also have we reached cultural stagnation, that old media still out competes new ones by such orders of magnitude

Where is the next Dahl? Why is there no modern Beatrix Potter? Kids still love those stories and style of writing, which is less trite than most of the modern children's books.

It does feel like stagnation, with lots of content being churned out but none of it with great staying power. Instead the old stuff is regurgitated endlessly with less and less of it's original soul.

◧◩◪
3. NateEa+N61[view] [source] 2023-02-19 02:37:44
>>jemmyw+Id
As a father of young kids, I cannot recommend John Klassen's "Hat" picture books enough:

I Want My Hat Back

This Is Not My Hat

We Found A Hat

The Rock From The Sky

They're beautiful exercises in minimal, precision watercolor. They're written with delightful economy, and have a rather Dahlian sense of justice and consequences.

He wrote them all within the last twelve years, IIRC.

For older kids, Pax (illustrated by Mr. Klassen in the edition we picked up) is a lovely piece of writing, vaguely like a cross between My Side Of The Mountain and Old Yeller, but less tragic than Old Yeller, with a deftly-handled thread about emotional awareness and responsibility for one's own choices woven throughout.

Oh, and the How To Train Your Dragon books, by Cressida Cowell, are wonderful, hilarious pieces of work about self-discovery, loyalty, friendship, and the hard, slow struggle to achieve mastery and skill in a world where people expect you to be something rather different than you are. Vastly, vastly better than the popular movies loosely inspired by them, and quite different - closer to a child-friendly Hitchhiker's Guide than the Hero's Journey of the films.

Great new classics are still being written - it's just that the winnowing function of passing decades hasn't yet run its course, so they're harder to find.

◧◩◪◨
4. oska+ye1[view] [source] 2023-02-19 03:46:55
>>NateEa+N61
> Great new classics are still being written - it's just that the winnowing function of passing decades hasn't yet run its course, so they're harder to find.

This is true, but I also think there are 'golden ages' for various genres of literature and I suspect we are not in a golden age for children's literature right now.

[go to top]