zlacker

[return to "GitHub Copilot, with “public code” blocked, emits my copyrighted code"]
1. kweing+v6[view] [source] 2022-10-16 20:27:21
>>davidg+(OP)
I’ve noticed that people tend to disapprove of AI trained on their profession’s data, but are usually indifferent or positive about other applications of AI.

For example, I know artists who are vehemently against DALL-E, Stable Diffusion, etc. and regard it as stealing, but they view Copilot and GPT-3 as merely useful tools. I also know software devs who are extremely excited about AI art and GPT-3 but are outraged by Copilot.

For myself, I am skeptical of intellectual property in the first place. I say go for it.

◧◩
2. sireat+dK1[view] [source] 2022-10-17 13:33:57
>>kweing+v6
I must be in the minority of programmers that I really really like Copilot but am indifferent about Stable Diffusion/Dall-E/midJourney.

Copilot on Python makes me x5 more productive. I used Copilot in Beta for a year and continue paying for it now.

For example: I can make a command line data wrangling script for a novel data set in a few minutes with a few prompts with full complement of extras (proper argparse parameters with sane defaults, ready to import etc etc). # reasonable comments included for free as well

Before copilot I could do the same in about 20-30minutes but my code would be a mess with little commenting. I would spend 30-60 minutes just looking up docs for various libraries.

Now without Copilot, if all I was doing was writing data wrangling scripts 4 hours a day I could approach this Copilot like productivity for a single task.

However with Copilot I can switch problem domains very quickly and remain productive.

Interestingly, on something like CSS or Javascript - Copilot is helping only slightly, maybe because my local training set is insufficient and my web-dev prompts are too generic.

So I think AI can be fantastic force multiplier in a skillset that you already are reasonably familiarity. I can handle the 5-10% wtf Python code that Copilot produces.

I do not particularly like copyrights and do wish Copilot had been trained on private Microsoft code as well.

[go to top]