zlacker

[return to "How Hacker News ranking really works: scoring, controversy, and penalties"]
1. david9+Jb[view] [source] 2013-11-26 11:56:16
>>jseip+(OP)
The post this morning, "Ask HN: What kind of side projects are you working on?"* got a lot of great responses and was killed because of it. There was nothing "controversial" about the post; it was merely popular with comments of what people are working on. This algorithm needs to be tweaked or HN risks losing its base.

*https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6799694

◧◩
2. kens+Yz[view] [source] 2013-11-26 16:03:31
>>david9+Jb
Yes, with 82 comments and 52 upvotes (currently), that post will get a fairly substantial penalty.

For the most part you don't need to be "afraid" of comments - an article is only penalized if it has more than 40 comments AND more comments than upvotes. Most articles have considerably more upvotes than comments, so commenting won't hurt them at all. But you might want check the upvote and comment numbers before adding a comment just in case...

[go to top]