zlacker

[return to "Data centers in space makes no sense"]
1. dathin+271[view] [source] 2026-02-04 01:53:04
>>ajyoon+(OP)
The really crazy thing is you don't need to know more then basic (non Hollywood) physics to know how dump this is

1. every gram you need to send to space is costly, a issue you don't have at ground level

2. cooling is a catastrophe, sure space is cold, but also a vacuum, so the cooling rate is roughly the infrared radiation rate. This means if you are not careful with the surface of a satellite it can end up being very slowly cooked by sunlight alone not including running any higher heat producing component (as it absorbs more heat from sunlight then it emits, there is a reason satellites are mostly white, silver or reflective gold in color). Sure better surface materials fix that, but not to a point where you would want to run any heavy compute on it.

3. zero repair-ability, most long running satellites have a lot of redundancy. Also at least if you are bulk buying Nvidea GPGPUs on single digit Million Euro basis it's not rare that 30% have some level of defect. Not necessary "fully broken" but "performs less good then it should/compared to other units" kind of broken.

4. radiation/solar wind protections are a huge problem. Heck even if you run things on earth it's a problem as long as your operations scale is large enough. In space things are magnitudes worse.

5. every rocket lunch causes atmospheric damage, so does every satellite evaporating on re-entry. That wasn't that relevant in the past, but might become a problem just for keeping stuff like Starlink running. We don't need to make it worse by putting datacenters into space.

6. Kessler Syndrom is real and could seriously hurt humanity as a whole, no reason to make it much more likely by putting things into space which don't need to go there.

Last but not least, wtf would you even want to do it?

There is zero benefit, non nada.

◧◩
2. joelth+DJ1[view] [source] 2026-02-04 07:50:17
>>dathin+271
> The really crazy thing is you don't need to know more then basic (non Hollywood) physics to know how dump this is

And yet journalists at major institutions have been repeating Musk's claims with very little skepticism ("xAI and SpaceX are merging to bring data centers to space").

◧◩◪
3. graeme+BW1[view] [source] 2026-02-04 09:30:47
>>joelth+DJ1
That sounds like what journalists usually do. They are reporters, and rarely have any real knowledge of what they report.
[go to top]