zlacker

>>flexdi+(OP)
Every time I see one of these nifty git tricks or workarounds I find myself wondering, “why not just use jj?”

You get a nicer, significantly simpler interface. You don’t need any tricks. You don’t have to google how to work yourself out of a bad state, ever. And you get near-perfect git compatibility (ie you can use jj on a shared git repo, doing all the same things, and your teammates won’t know the difference).

I’ve wondered if there is a psychological thing here: someone who spent time memorizing all the git nonsense may have some pride in that (which is earned, certainly), that introduces some mental friction in walking away???

>>swaits+JWe
It’s a bit like qwertz. Sure, it is not optimal, there are better alternatives available. But it is good enough, and it is universal. That trumps a 5% typing improvement on my own custom keyboard layout at the cost of not being able to use my coworkers keyboard.

Also, I dislike all of the alternate git frontends I tried, because they are opinionated in a way they clash with my workflow.

Moreover, I don’t think the git CLI is that bad. Once you learn some basic concepts, it makes a lot of sense and is pretty consistent.

Most problems people report stem from a refusal to learn the underlying structure and models. That is on them. And when using a different frontend, they don’t disappear either. They are just abstracted, to allow you to avoid learning them. But they are still there, and you will probably still need to know them at some point.