zlacker

[return to "UK Petition: Do not introduce Digital ID cards"]
1. jen729+ww[view] [source] 2025-09-28 21:57:41
>>DamonH+(OP)
I don't trust the UK government either. But I'm both British and Australian and I see the need for a centralised identity service.

Because the alternative is that we provide our passport to every online service that 'needs' to verify our identity. Then – lo, would you believe it! – they get hacked, and now all of our data is in the wild again.

I'd much rather the government, who already know everything about me because may I remind you they issued the documents, had some way of that company querying my 'verified identity'. They might do it by me providing, say, an ID number string which is looked up. That's all they get: my ID number. In return, they get confirmation that I am who I say I am.

Oh by the way I already have at least 2 of these ID numbers as an Australian citizen. My aforementioned passport, and my driver licence. Both of which I know I should keep 'private', lol, but if I want to interact with the world in any meaningful way the reality is that I spray these digits – along with my date of birth and address and whatever else they ask for – all over the goddamned place.

But sure, centralised identity is bad.

◧◩
2. wkat42+2A[view] [source] 2025-09-28 22:29:33
>>jen729+ww
> Because the alternative is that we provide our passport to every online service that 'needs' to verify our identity.

I really really really don't want to 'verify my identity' everywhere. Why the F is that normalised these days?? If I buy something online my payment and delivery address is all they should need. And all they've had to have for the last 30 years

> I'd much rather the government, who already know everything about me because may I remind you they issued the documents, had some way of that company querying my 'verified identity'.

Um yeah but right now they don't know what you do with your life all the time. Anna have absolutely no business to.

◧◩◪
3. phanto+DT[view] [source] 2025-09-29 02:33:33
>>wkat42+2A
As an adult, you probably need to authenticate yourself in the following situation.

opening a bank account, getting a credit card, getting a mortgage or a loan, buying a flight ticket, signing up for internet service, signing for mobile services, buying a concert ticket and the list goes on.

What's common here is the service provider need to know you are actually the person say it is you and not someone else.

Back in the old days where we apply the service in person, you can take your driving license or passport to authenticate yourself, but with myriad of services now moving online, we need a centralised system that mimic the physical ID.

◧◩◪◨
4. wkat42+yj1[view] [source] 2025-09-29 08:28:28
>>phanto+DT
For a flight ticket I just ID myself at the airport so that's not an issue. For concert tickets I don't need to do this now. For internet service I absolutely don't need that, all they need to know is that I pay.

And mortgage, bank etc I just do on premise of course. These things are rare and important enough to warrant to just go there.

[go to top]