I see some core team on this thread, so just wanted to say THANK YOU! Awesome job! Keep fighting for the users!
I'm totally the wrong person to offer recommendations on mobile, but so far it works very well for me, but then, I use almost no third party apps, and none of them are Play store only. My only complaint is the hardware (outside of their control).
I did do about three weeks of research, as I worried that maybe a number of apps wouldn't run on it or needed some form of deep attestation. Didn't find much, OpsGenie and other work apps are happy with the GOS level of attestation provided.
Great to have Google kicked off the phone. So nice to shut off the network permission for any apps that only require an internet connection to serve ads.
One tip from me, if you came from stock Pixel: You can download the default Pixel sounds and set them up like it was. Have a look for "Your New Adventure" online, the message sound is "Eureka".
Except the default browser is Chromium with some changes
This reminds me of a recent HN comment I saw that suggested using Firefox was "kicking Google where it hurts" or something like that
Like Firefox, this project depends on Google. For the hardware, the web browser and who knows what else
It even offers a sandboxed Google Play Store
It tries to copy Google paternalism
It swaps a Google mothership for a Graphene mothership
What if the computer owner does not want a mothership
Can connections to Graphene servers be blocked, i.e., are these connections optional or mandatory
Even Netguard which works on any hardware and does not require root makes unnecessary connections to ipinfo.io servers effectively giving them a list of almost every domain the user's phone trying to access
If the concern is apps that only require internet connection for ads, Netguard solves that problem without root
Most apps but not all will try to connect to the internet at some point, even if you never use them
The user-hostile design of Android is that apps keep running in the background after they are "closed"
(There are crude apps one can use to automate manually killing each process with "Force stop" but no one uses them. This doesn't prevent apps from trying to access the internet on some preset schedule)
Netguard will show when apps try to connect and block the connections. It provides DNS logs and PCAPs.
One does not even need Netguard to see this subversive activity
Try this at home
Enable IP forwarding on a computer you can control, i.e., one that is running an OS you can compile yourself such as Linux or BSD
Put the phone on the same network as this computer
Set the phone's gateway address to the address of the computer
Run tcpdump on the computer and filter for the phone's IP address
Is making a connection to our API a cause for concern? If that is the case, we welcome OSS projects to user our local IP databases, which includes our free IPinfo Lite database that we primarily designed for firewall and privacy applications.
GrapheneOS definitely doesn't use it. It doesn't contact any third-party APIs. Everything is well documented: https://grapheneos.org/faq#default-connections
In both cases, they could opt to download our database locally and use it through their own API system.
We sponsor the AlmaLinux Foundation through a data sponsorship for their mirroring system: https://almalinux.org/blog/2024-08-07-mirrors-1-to-400/
But since privacy is a major concern for them, they should just use our IP-to-country database and host an API themselves on top of it: https://ipinfo.io/lite
We are happy to support and be part of any software that want to use our data.
I agree that it would be a more privacy-friendly solution for them to host their own API, but that got me thinking, wouldn't it be possible to just let users download the IPinfo data and use it locally? Does IPinfo offer database downloads? That's also how the Server-Status Firefox extension (https://github.com/tdulcet/Server-Status) works (but it doesn't use IPinfo). Also asking for potential personal use: How does the quality of IPinfo data compare to MaxMind, DB-IP, etc?