zlacker

[return to "Graphene OS: a security-enhanced Android build"]
1. usuall+8q[view] [source] 2025-07-25 01:05:34
>>madars+(OP)
I was tempted to use this but when I looked into the team behind it there seemed to be some issues as exposed by Louis Rossman here: https://youtu.be/Dl1x1Dy-ej4.

Instead, I installed CalyxOS and have been using it over a year now and I'm very happy with it. Check it out.

◧◩
2. onli+AT[view] [source] 2025-07-25 06:19:27
>>usuall+8q
You are exactly right. To summarise for those who do not want to watch a video, the video shows communications with Graphenes lead developer in which he was extremely hostile and threatened Rossman. It also goes into how said developers hallucinates being attacked by specific other sites, like a Linux YouTube channel that obviously did nothing to him. His goons then attack those projects.

You have to be aware that you give that person root when you use Graphene. All possible technical improvements aside this is a very big risk. He claimed he would step back after the video released, then called that a lie and continued with everything.

Calyx seems to be the best alternative right now without such a risk factor.

◧◩◪
3. bernou+hZ[view] [source] 2025-07-25 07:14:48
>>onli+AT
I second this opinion, with some additional nuance.

While I don't think the developers necessarily hallucinates being attacked (i.e. given the nature of the project, I would expect them to be persons of interest, be it from surveillance agencies, or even state actors), the main issue with Rossmann is their claim that he is either personally directing harassment against GOS, or colluding with and encouraging other communities to harass (mainly Kiwifarms, Techlore, CalyxOS, and other Android related FOSS projects). This claim seems to originate then cascade from Rossmann leaving the comment "Informative, but unfortunate" on TechLore's video criticizing GOS's leadership. This is taken as explicit support of TechLore community's / KiwiFarms alleged harrassement on the lead GOS developer, and this has somehow been cascaded and blown out of proportions, and considered by GOS developers as evidence of Rossmann's wrong doing against them.

As mentioned somewhere else, I am using GrapheneOS since 2 or 3 years now, based on Rossmann recommendations. The software is very good, pretty much native Android experience, but without the extra alleged Google snooping / root access. Rossmann himself seemed to have stopped using it as his main device because of fear of retaliation given that the GOS devs could potentially target him. Better safe than sorry. I still use it because I am not that high profile of a person, and generally will use throwaway when it comes to discussing anything GOS related at this point. The overall leadership however, based on Rossmann's and later my personal interactions with them however, did leave a bad after taste.

◧◩◪◨
4. other8+Ld1[view] [source] 2025-07-25 09:48:07
>>bernou+hZ
> Rossmann himself seemed to have stopped using it as his main device because of fear of retaliation given that the GOS devs could potentially target him.

But he didn't. It's clear in his later videos that he was still using GrapheneOS, I believe even for months after the video.

> Better safe than sorry.

People who are familiar with how GrapheneOS updates work wouldn't agree. No identifiers are sent to the update server, so targeted updates aren't possible that way. Also, update servers only host static files. If Rossmann was really that worried, all he'd have to do is use a VPN. But that was all just a huge dramatic act so his video would get more views, and possibly to entertain his fellow Kiwi Farms members.

◧◩◪◨⬒
5. bornfr+Ls1[view] [source] 2025-07-25 12:22:35
>>other8+Ld1
> > Better safe than sorry.

> People who are familiar with how GrapheneOS updates work wouldn't agree. No identifiers are sent to the update server, so targeted updates aren't possible that way. Also, update servers only host static files...

We are literally talking about an OS here. It has an almost total control over your phone - what does it matter if the updates can be targeted? The GOS could snoop on their users and turn into malware only if it figures out that this is Rossmann's phone.

This is what is keeping me from installing GOS too. Interaction from the developers seems very aggressive towards the competing OSs, which doesn't inspire much trust. Who is reviewing the GOS changes? Are they really all benign? In the end you need to trust someone, but I'm not sure GOS is more trustworthy than LineageOS (which has a bigger community, more developers and /e/os building on top of them).

Happy to be convinced otherwise.

[go to top]