zlacker

[return to "My AI skeptic friends are all nuts"]
1. agnish+wH[view] [source] 2025-06-03 02:42:50
>>tablet+(OP)
I think the key premise here is that one can effectively and efficiently audit code that the LLM is producing.

I doubt that. First, human attention and speed is very limited. Second, when I see something, I am already predisposed to assume that it is right (or at the very least, my subsequent inquiries are extremely narrow and anchored around the solution I have seen presented to me.)

◧◩
2. nprate+301[view] [source] 2025-06-03 06:16:08
>>agnish+wH
Yeah the problem is the fatigue of repeatedly reviewing code.

You do a few iterations until code runs, review carefully but notice a bug. So you do another iteration and 40% of code changes. Now you need to review again but you need to understand how the changes fit in.

Repeat this a few times and it becomes very tiring.

Ultimately you can't trust them not to do stupid shit. Your tests fail and you tell it to stop that? Sure, we can just catch those exceptions and the tests pass, etc. You get pissed off an tell it to FIX the CODE so the tests pass and the cycle continues.

It's like working with a potentially gifted moron.

[go to top]