zlacker

[return to "Google makes Android development private, will continue open source releases"]
1. bitsan+5i[view] [source] 2025-03-26 20:42:08
>>colone+(OP)
Android has been bad-faith open source for as long as I can remember. Android is look-but-dont-touch source. Its massive codebase that requires immense resources to build is not open for negotiation, its existence is to serve Google's whims.

Android was already a platform on life support. Google has wielded its authority to dictate how apps should behave such that even 3rd party stores do not stray far from Google's rules. Users of android phones have little hope to run a program from 5 years ago, or to roll back a bad update in an era full of bad updates.

◧◩
2. dangus+Uq[view] [source] 2025-03-26 21:35:13
>>bitsan+5i
Ah yes, the most popular mobile operating system in the world is “on life support.”

iOS must not even exist anymore because it’s closed source. I can feel my iPhone disintegrating before my eyes.

Look-but-don’t-touch source, except for how there are multiple successful alternative builds like /e/os, LineageOS, and GrapheneOS

The second largest country in the whole world gets by using Android without Google Play services even being available there, with Android commanding a 77 percent marketshare.

https://microg.org/

Sure, I fully agree that Google isn’t super enthusiastic about open source for Android beyond the ways in which it benefits them, but there’s a lot of hyperbole in your comment.

◧◩◪
3. nani8o+7U[view] [source] 2025-03-27 01:14:29
>>dangus+Uq
In recent Android versions increasingly more features got moved into proprietary modules. A few years ago AOSP felt pretty much the same as proprietary Android.

Now changes in toolkits made it so that e.g. copying text from apps sometimes doesn't work. Google Android has a work around by using OCR (?) in the overview to select text. I feel like the former change is directly related to the ability of the OS to copy text anyway. This might not be a deliberate choice to limit AOSP but it shows how they design with proprietary Android in mind. Thus AOSP gets less useful as an OS as the design is not well thought out.

[go to top]