zlacker

[return to "Carlsen quits World Rapid and Blitz championship after dress code disagreement"]
1. david-+BL[view] [source] 2024-12-28 12:19:19
>>throwu+(OP)
The context in which this happened matters a lot.

There have been tensions between the FIDE organization and top players like Carlsen since the latter have been promoting an alternative chess organization around Freestyle chess (aka Chesss960), which has slightly different rules.

I.e. this is less about "dress code enforcement" and it is more about "Carlsen is fed up with the FIDE organization in general".

◧◩
2. Frustr+oW[view] [source] 2024-12-28 14:17:51
>>david-+BL
Sure. Beef with an organization.

But if you are going to bother signing up, is 'jeans' really the hill to die on?

If the beef is with the organization, just boycott altogether.

Otherwise, just put on some pants.

EDIT:

Perhaps the downvotes are because of disagreement with methods of protest?

What brings greater attention to your cause?

1. A boycott, you just don't go to the event? And make a press statement about it, that probably doesn't get any headlines.

or

2. Sign up, go, then angrily get disqualified, based on some stupid rule, which gets a lot of headlines, and attention focused on silly rules of the organization?

Guess, if the goal was to effect change, then maybe this was the correct move. But if it was just being pissi, then why bother signing up, you know the rules, so just don't go.

◧◩◪
3. reaper+SX[view] [source] 2024-12-28 14:33:47
>>Frustr+oW
Otherwise, just put on some pants.

I agree. This isn't high school rebellion. Is the real world.

Adults dress appropriately for different places and different times. You can be denied admission to a restaurant, a business, an office meeting, or even a concert for not dressing appropriately. This is no different.

Grow up and put on some pants. Be sloppy in your own home.

◧◩◪◨
4. ruthma+791[view] [source] 2024-12-28 16:09:00
>>reaper+SX
Jeans are pants and wearing them isn't sloppy.
◧◩◪◨⬒
5. SoftTa+Us1[view] [source] 2024-12-28 18:29:14
>>ruthma+791
I've had jobs where I'd absolutely be sent home if I turned up wearing jeans. Might be a little less likely these days but there are many jobs and situations where this still applies.

It's also about showing respect to the host, you dress nicely. Would you wear jeans to church or to a wedding?

◧◩◪◨⬒⬓
6. Frustr+qi3[view] [source] 2024-12-29 14:42:41
>>SoftTa+Us1
I agree. Just a decade ago, jeans would have me escorted from work. The business dress code was 'pants', jeans were not allowed.

Everyone is arguing about 'jean's not being a big deal. And, all dress codes are wrong. So, can a female player wear a bikini? By the arguments here, then yes, that should be allowed. Would it interfere with game play? I think yes.

Can someone wear a bright orange Sarang with blinking lights?

How do you draw the line? Doesn't there need to be a line somewhere so there isn't chaos? It's just that todays generation now thinks 'jeans' are ok. 20 years ago they were not.

[go to top]