But they make a good point: if you exclude the smaller providers, that’s where the drugs and CSAM and the freewheeling dialog go. Assuming it’s their policy goal to deter these categories of speech, I’m not sure how you do that without a net fine enough to scoop up the 4chans of the world too.
It’s not the behavior of a confident, open, healthy society, though…
CSAM is absolutely horrible.. but CSAM laws don't stop CSAM (primarily this happens from group defections).
Instead it's just a form of tarring, in this case unliked speech, by associating it with the most horrible thing anyone can think of.