zlacker

>>matt_d+(OP)
Abstract. Logic programming has a long history. The representative of logic programming in practice, the language Prolog, has been introduced more than 50 years ago. The main features of Prolog are still present today: a Prolog program is a set of predicate definitions executed by resolution steps with a backtracking search strategy. The use of back- tracking was justified by efficiency reasons when Prolog was invented. However, its incompleteness destroys the elegant connection of logic pro- gramming and the underlying Horn clause logic and causes difficulties to teach logic programming. Moreover, the restriction to predicates hinders an adequate modeling of real world problems, which are often functions from input to output data, and leads to unnecessarily inefficient exe- cutions. In this paper we show a way to overcome these problems. By transforming predicates and goals into functions and nested expressions, one can evaluate them with a demand-driven strategy which might re- duce the number of computation steps and avoid infinite search spaces. Replacing backtracking by complete search strategies with new imple- mentation techniques closes the gap between the theory and practice of logic programming. In this way, we can keep the ideas of logic program- ming in future programming systems.

>>xelxeb+th2
Depth-first backtracking is trivial to implement, and it's trivial to blend into the language. Breadth-first backtracking is much harder to implement, and I'm not sure that it's trivial to build into a language (though this may be a lack of imagination).

Icon had both, but depth-first backtracking was the default and trivial to use, while breadth-first backtracking required using "co-expressions" (co-routines), though at least Icon had a trivial syntax for causing procedure argument expressions to be made into co-expressions. But Icon's approach does not make breadth-first backtracking be a first-class language feature like depth-first backtracking, and this is where my imagination gets stuck. To be fair, I've not truly thought much about this problem.