zlacker

[return to "Go(lang): Robust generic functions on slices"]
1. jerf+JT2[view] [source] 2024-02-24 03:45:02
>>signa1+(OP)
A missing tidbit that may help contextualize this post: One of the things about Go that surprised me is that if you have a slice which does not represent the full capacity of the underlying array, you can go ahead and reslice it up to that full capacity even though it's a panic to access the things you're reslicing directly: https://go.dev/play/p/oThz2bNFwgr

Consequently, the GC has to assume that anything forward of any given slice into the underlying array may become accessible in the future as there is legal Go that can access it. It's still memory safe, but it surprised me.

I had some code that was using my incorrect belief that slices could not be resliced up in size to implement some light security boundaries. Fortunately it was still legal, because the code in question simply didn't slice things larger and it's not like I was allowing arbitrary user-supplied code to run, so it was still correct in what it was doing. But I was expecting the runtime to scream if I did somehow screw it up when in fact it may not, depending on the exact capacity and what happened when.

It's also asymmetric, as far as I know; you can slice forward into the array if there is capacity, but if you've got a slice that starts after index 0 in the backing array you can't use that slice to walk back into the underlying array. That is, with

     s := []int{11, 12, 13, 14, 15}
     s = s[2:]
as far as I know, 11 and 12 are no longer accessible to any legal Go code (not using "unsafe") after that second line executes.

Corrections (again not involving "unsafe", it's obvious those two values are still accessible through "unsafe") welcome. I was wrong once, it's easy to believe I could be wrong again.

◧◩
2. never_+bV2[view] [source] 2024-02-24 04:13:50
>>jerf+JT2
It is reinforcing my belief that language design is hard. Go is supposed to be a simple language, one may write it for long time, but there will be some trap you discover once in a while.
[go to top]