zlacker

[return to "GitHub Copilot available for JetBrains and Neovim"]
1. mewse+4T[view] [source] 2021-10-27 22:39:24
>>orph+(OP)
I’ve never understood the value proposition for Copilot.

In terms of difficulty, writing code is maybe on average a two out of ten.

On average, maintaining code you wrote recently is probably a three out of ten in terms of difficulty, and maintaining code somebody else wrote or code from a long time ago probably rises to around a five out of ten.

Debugging misbehaving code is probably a seven out of ten or higher.

GitHub Copilot is optimising the part of the process that was already the easiest, and makes the other parts harder because it moves you from the “I wrote this” path to the “somebody else wrote this” path.

Even during the initial write, it changes the writing process from programming (which is easy) to understanding somebody else’s code to ensure that it’s right before accepting the suggestion (which is much less easy). I just don’t understand how this is a net time/energy savings?

◧◩
2. baby+4b1[view] [source] 2021-10-28 00:55:02
>>mewse+4T
Did you try it? Because I've been using it for weeks and it makes me read these types of comments as "I don't understand the value of the internet" or "what's the purpose of owning a phone".

It's night and day if you have it enabled or not. There's just no question about the value proposition once you start using it.

I mean, you can tell comments here from people who have actually been using it, and people who have not tried it.

◧◩◪
3. b21582+wd1[view] [source] 2021-10-28 01:22:12
>>baby+4b1
> Because I've been using it for weeks and it makes me read these types of comments as "I don't understand the value of the internet" or "what's the purpose of owning a phone".

And yet apart from making this very inaccurate comparison you haven't made any argument for why such a thing as Copilot would be useful to anyone. How do you personally find Copilot useful? And why do you think someone whose job demands more than copy/pasting boilerplate code should try Copilot? The onus is on you to convince the skeptics.

◧◩◪◨
4. baby+UG1[view] [source] 2021-10-28 06:23:50
>>b21582+wd1
First, why would I need to argue this? Just try it and see if it’s useful for you. I know people who don’t use IDEs or don’t use syntax highlighting and it doesn’t seem to bother them much, so who knows.

Second, I’ve actually answered elsewhere in this thread.

[go to top]