zlacker

[return to "Political Detox Week – No politics on HN for one week (2016)"]
1. baseme+K9[view] [source] 2021-01-15 01:36:39
>>notion+(OP)
Im not sure why citizens of representative democracies would want to inhibit political discussion. Presumably one of the benefits of living in such a regime is the ability to participate in policy formulation through voting, political campaigns and various forms of public service. As a result, would it not be reasonable to assume that most of these individuals are very knowledgeable about a variety of aspects of public policy? Therefore the majority of political discussion would be rigorous, fact based and consider a wide variety of points of view.

Analogously it would seem that citizens of dictatorship-based regimes don’t have to worry about these details (hopefully the dictator and their lieutenants have taken care of everything) and can focus on enjoying their lives.

◧◩
2. throw_+Ob[view] [source] 2021-01-15 01:51:51
>>baseme+K9
> Im not sure why citizens of representative democracies would want to inhibit political discussion.

It's turning HN into r/politics, I personally don't come on HN for that, there is already many many places online where political discussions happen, like reddit. When I say politics here I'm talking about USA cantered partisan politics.

HN is a great place for tech discussion AND it's also an opportunity to talk directly to founders, or important people and technologists in IT, in a better format than Twitter. I'd like for HN to stay in that niche.

◧◩◪
3. stjohn+nY2[view] [source] 2021-01-15 21:17:14
>>throw_+Ob
How though? You don't have to click on the discussion? Just ignore it and move on to the next item. I do think it might be a good think to require a [political] tag or something though.
[go to top]