zlacker

[return to "YouTube’s Algorithm Incentivizes the Wrong Behavior"]
1. roster+gh[view] [source] 2019-06-14 18:23:37
>>furcyd+(OP)
Ah, the classic “think of the children!” argument. It is no one’s responsibility other than the parent to ensure their child isn’t watching inappropriate content (which will be different for every family and individual).

This article suggests that machine learning and collaborative filtering are incapable of producing healthy recommendations. I beg to differ, the New York Times may not like the result but they work for the vast majority of users on any service with too much content to manually curate.

◧◩
2. RHSeeg+gl[view] [source] 2019-06-14 18:49:28
>>roster+gh
> It is no one’s responsibility other than the parent to ensure their child isn’t watching inappropriate content

Society has had laws in place to prevent children from viewing things they should not be (inappropriate movies, magazines, etc).

◧◩◪
3. scarfa+Pm[view] [source] 2019-06-14 18:58:40
>>RHSeeg+gl
What law is there to prevent a kid from going on the internet and going to “inappropriate” sites? Watching video on cable? Finding their Dad’s Playboy magazine back in the day?
◧◩◪◨
4. Fins+1r[view] [source] 2019-06-14 19:29:13
>>scarfa+Pm
On cable there are ways to lock out channels, setting ratings on the TV and all that. If dad doesn't hide his Playboy well enough, it's obviously on him to fix it.

On the internet it is much more difficult, of course, and we can't realistically expect some shady offshore site from implementing age checks, let alone recommendation algorithms. But Google is a public, respected company from a first world country that claims to be promoting social good (which, of course, is marketing BS, and even if it weren't I would not want their idea of social good, but still). You'd think that they would invest some effort into not showing inappropriate content to kids at least. But no, they throw up their hands and go on ideological witch hunts instead.

◧◩◪◨⬒
5. scarfa+4O[view] [source] 2019-06-14 23:06:39
>>Fins+1r
I’ve got an idea - don’t let your kids get on YouTube and only allow them to get on curated sites. You can easily lock down a mobile device to only allow certain apps/curated websites.
[go to top]