zlacker

[return to "Too many laws, too many prisoners"]
1. kiba+R6[view] [source] 2010-07-23 20:50:56
>>gruseo+(OP)
I think we have seen for ourselves how dangerous democracies can be when mixed with fears.

Alas, people will continue to argues that democracy is the best form of government despite its various flaws.

◧◩
2. anigbr+I9[view] [source] 2010-07-23 22:09:13
>>kiba+R6
as opposed to what? Every time I try to come up with an answer for that question I get stuck at 'dictatorship headed by the fairest and wisest person I know.' It's probably just a coincidence, but that person usually turns out to be me :)

What's your alternative good?

◧◩◪
3. Brando+lb[view] [source] 2010-07-23 23:00:09
>>anigbr+I9
In The Republic, Plato argues that the best form of rule is philosopher-kings; your answer seems to be the same. I tend to agree, but of course the logistics of finding such a ruler are difficult and subject to corruption.
◧◩◪◨
4. bff+2k[view] [source] 2010-07-24 05:46:33
>>Brando+lb
I much prefer Zeno's Republic, where everyone is equal but strives to be wise.

Really, I think that there is no such thing as a perfect government, only a perfect citizenry, because the power of a government is always derived from the people within it. A philosopher king would not be able to maintain power unless either A) he was omnipotent or B) the people allowed him to remain in power.

◧◩◪◨⬒
5. pbhjpb+gr[view] [source] 2010-07-24 13:57:43
>>bff+2k
or C) he was tyrannical or D) the army supported him or E) the people didn't care or F) he subdued the people with drugs or G) ...

False dichotomies are the sceptre of the philosopher king‽

[go to top]